Natural Slate vs. Composite Slate Roofing

December 5, 2025

Natural Slate vs. Composite Slate Roofs: Which is Best for your Missouri Home?

Slate roofing has a timeless, upscale look that many homeowners love. But traditional natural slate can be heavy and expensive, which is why composite (synthetic) slate has become a popular alternative. We offer options from trusted brands like Ludowici and composite options from Brava and DaVinci.

If you’re considering a slate-style roof in Eureka or the greater St. Louis area, it’s important to understand the differences between natural and composite slate.

What Is Natural Slate Roofing?

Natural slate is a stone roofing material that’s been used for centuries. It’s known for:

Exceptional longevity – Often 75–100+ years when properly installed
Classic, high-end appearance
Fire resistance
Low water absorption

However, it also has some challenges:

Very heavy – Many homes need structural reinforcement to support natural slate
Higher material and installation cost
More fragile during installation and maintenance – Requires experienced installers

What Is Composite (Synthetic) Slate?

Composite slate is designed to mimic the look of natural slate using advanced materials such as engineered polymers, rubber, or recycled materials. Quality composite slate products offer:

Much lighter weight – Often suitable for standard roof structures without reinforcement
Lower cost than natural slate
Impact resistance – Many products are engineered to handle hail and storms well
Consistent appearance – Less variation than natural stone, which some homeowners prefer

Comparing Natural vs. Composite Slate

Appearance

Natural slate offers a truly authentic, unique look with natural color variation.
Composite slate closely replicates the look from the ground, with more uniform color and shape.

Weight and Structure

Natural slate is significantly heavier and may require structural upgrades.
Composite slate is lighter and easier to install on typical residential structures.

Cost

Natural slate is one of the most expensive roofing materials.
Composite slate is still a premium option, but generally more budget-friendly than natural slate.

Durability and Maintenance

Natural slate can last a century or more but requires specialized installation and careful maintenance.
Composite slate is engineered for durability and impact resistance, with warranties that often range from 30–50 years.

Which Slate Option Is Right for You?

Natural slate may be a good fit if:

You’re restoring or building a high-end home
You’re prepared for the higher cost and structural requirements
You want a truly traditional, authentic slate roof

Composite slate may be the better choice if:

You want the look of slate without the extreme weight and cost
You live in a hail-prone area and want good impact resistance
You’re looking for a balance between aesthetics, performance, and budget

During a roofing consultation, we’ll review your home’s structure, your design preferences, and your budget to help you choose the best option.

Interested in a slate-style roof in Eureka or the St. Louis area? Call Perfect Pitch Roofing & Exteriors, Inc. at (314) 596-1391 to schedule a free consultation or schedule online and compare natural and composite slate options for your home.

< Older Post

Newer Post >